1

Persistent blisters with 3 pairs of shoes - help please! (Read 1288 times)


Yoda the 4-eared cat

    Hello, I'm sure this question has ready come up a billion times but I need some help combatting persistent blisters that are starting to take the shine off running for me. I've been running for about 18 months, around 30 kms a week. I've been through 3 pairs of shoes and with each pair the blisters get more frequent and severe. They are always on the bottom arch of my foot a bit behind the big toe joint. For prevention I've tried 3 types of socks, lubricant, blister-prevention tape and 3 types of blister-protection gel bandages, in varying combinations. My brother, an ex runner, tells me it's down to the shoes. I've bought all 3 pairs of shoes of different brands from the only specialist running shop in my town who seem unable to suggest anything for what could be causing these arch blisters. Does anyone have some suggestions as to whether I need to go down or up a size, or a particuler shoe shape? As running shoes are kind of expensive I would prefer to get it right rather than discovering one month down the track that I've wasted another 130€. Sorry for the metrics and euros, I live in France. Smile
    Wingz


    Professional Noob

      I actually ended up getting a callus in that same spot! Shocked That was because I insisted on putting an insert into the bottom of the shoe and the shoe and it were slightly different shapes. Do they have Moleskin in France? If not, ducttape might help too. Once you get those blisters healed up, tape-up BEFORE the run and see if that doesn't help. Others have different suggestions...

      Roads were made for journeys...

      zoom-zoom


      rectumdamnnearkilledem

        I've had a couple of blisters in that area, though none were too severe. Usually they were the result of shoes that were too narrow (even in wide width the Kayano 13 was too narrow for me) and/or had a poorly placed seam. Shoes that are too wide can be a problem, too. I had a weird blister that started when my favorite shoes hit around 70 miles, too, but after a couple of weeks it was no longer a problem, so it was probably just breaking-in kind of strangely for me. Have you ever tried the Blister Shield powder? That stuff is AMAZING.

        Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

        remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

             ~ Sarah Kay


        ...---...

          Amputate the toe. You'll never have blisters there again. Just kidding. Sounds like the shoes don't fit your fore foot well...too much sliding. Either that or your mechanics simply make you prone to blisters. Try the ankle high panty hose. Seriously. It worked for us in the Army on long road marches, in those ridiculously heavy ill fitting boots and carrying all that heavy crap.

          San Francisco - 7/29/12

          Warrior Dash Ohio II - 8/26/12

          Chicago - 10/7/12


          chrimbler


            You could try this...when I was in the army, whenever we got blisters we would take a needle and some thread, poke the needle throught the blister, then pull the thread through, leave the tail end in the blister, cut the thread, then just let it heal naturally! This will form a callous around the thread and you will never get another blister in that spot again! Big grin And for all of you that may be thinking about infection... HTFU!!... I never got infected Tongue Chris
            Run like you stole it!
            Nev


              I had problems wit hblisters on both arches when I started wearing orthotics - I tried everything and although compede worked for a while in the end the blisters were bigger than the plasters so they no longer worked. I tried the HTFU route with some success - people I ran with now think I am some kind of mental case because i just popped the blisters, squeezed the blood out and carried on running. This is ok for a while but I dont think it is a good solution long term. What has worked for me is to wipe the area with surgical spirit several times per day for a week or so. This hardens the skin up but stops it from cracking - did the trick for me. Hope you can find a solution as it is soooo much easier to run when you dont have blisters. Good luck Nev
              peggya111


                Do you have access to a doctor with Sports medicine as a specialty? Perhaps they would have some suggestions that could help. Good luck and keep us posted.
                Upcoming Races Disneyland Half AF Halloween Fun Run Disney World Half Ogden Marathon (I think...)
                  The only time I can remeber when I got blister on the front part of inner arch (which I think is where you're explaining...) is when the insole is too thick or too high (arch) like it happens when you slide an extra insole like orthotics; or when I bought shoes that's a half a size bigger than it should per recommendation of the store guy. For the latter, in general, what happens is that the widest part of the shoe no longer fits where the widest part of your foot fits in (because you're getting a shoe that's a half a size too big). Yes, your feet will swell up a bit when you run but not to that extent (of course, it's slightly an individual matter...). The reason why they say that is because way back when they built shoes with toe box collapsing on your toes. Now we have (in general) a "U" shape reinforcement wrapping around the toe box to keep the toe box 3-deminsional. If the toe box still collapses and pushes the big toe down (and causing black toe nail), then there's something wrong with that particular shoe--this should NOT happen. But old wife's tale stays alive and many of the shoe sales people still tell you to get a half a size to sometimes even a full size bigger shoe than necessary (or you SHOULD get). Ceonsequently, your arch will slide backward a bit and get the inner arch rubbed against the narrower part of the shoe. I'm telling ya; I don't work for these guys, I don't represent them; I don't have any connection with them--but if you're getting a blister problem from rubbing, try a blue low-friction patch called Engo (I think their website is www.runengo.com or something like that...google search them). It really does work (though I still think this is just s tampering and you should really find out the real cause of it and eliminat it). I do have a few samples at hand; if you're interested, I can send you a few to try out. Honest to God, I don't get paid by them or anything like that! ;o)


                  Renee the dog

                    Dijon, I also got a blister on my arch and other various places on my foot. I have a slightly narrow foot. Someone recommended (like the ankle high pantyhose suggestion above) a liner sock inside my sock. Voilà, problem solved. So now I wear two pair of super thin running socks each time I run. Good luck finding your answer. You will!

                    GOALS 2012: UNDECIDED

                    GOALS 2011: LIVE!!!

                      I did a quick Google and found that blisters on the arches generally mean that your shoes don't fit correctly. Either your arch is too low for your shoes or your shoes aren't the right size so your arch is support is in the wrong place. I also read that this can be caused by shoes that don't flex enough in the middle. Teresa
                        Do you have a bunion? My podiatrist explained bunions can cause the area behind the big toe to blister from something or another pinching from it.


                        Yoda the 4-eared cat

                          Hi to everyone who has answered. Thanks so much for your advice and encouragement. Smile I was just thinking that the only time I can remember running without blisters recently was inexplicably when I did my first half-marathon in November Undecided . The only reason I can come up with is that it was maybe cold enough (2°C) to negate any friction. Nobby415, you may be right about my shoes being half a size too big as I went up half a size for me last two pairs, although I did also have blisters from the first pair, though not so severe until they were approaching the end of the life. Thanks for tip on Engo, I'll see if I can suss them out around here. Marktman, actually I do have the beginnings of a bunion and it's bigger on the foot where I get the worst blisters. I might get on to my GP, who while not a sports specialist is himself a runner and might be able to refer me to a podiatrist. Nev, you mentioned toughening the skin with surgical spirits. I thnk I've seen elsewhere advice to 'tan' skin in blister prone areas using some product or another. Has anyone heard of anything like this? Thanks again to all Smile