Generic Prescript. costs = Name Brand...huh? (Read 1195 times)

zoom-zoom


rectumdamnnearkilledem

    Can someone explain this to me?  A medication my son takes recently went generic.  We thought "yay, $5/month, vs. $35!"  Nope, still $35.  Color me confused.  So why not just fill it as name brand if the price to the patient is the same?  And why are some generics in the same class of drugs priced at $5, but not all?  I assume this is an issue with our lame-o drug coverage program...correct?

    Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

    remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

         ~ Sarah Kay

    keeponrunning


      Move to Canada.  All prescription medications I have taken in my life have been covered by tax money.  Big grin

      Sulphur Springs 50km-- Ancaster, ON-- May 28, 2022

      Tally in the Valley 12 hours-- Dundas, ON -- July 30, 2022 (Support SickKids Toronto)

      Stokely Creek-- 56km-- Sault Ste. Marie, ON-- Sept. 24, 2022

       

       

      zoom-zoom


      rectumdamnnearkilledem

        Ha, I'd love to live in Canada, eh!

        Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

        remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

             ~ Sarah Kay

          One data point: Synthroid (Bristol-Myers Squibb) went off patent a while back.  SYNTHROID is still considered a brand-name drug and falls into a different (higher) tier than its fully generic counterparts made by other companies.  For some reason, the various generic equivalents don't seem to behave precisely the same, even in the same patient.  The largest body of data exists for Synthroid, so some docs prescribe Synthroid and disallow generic substitution.

          "I want you to pray as if everything depends on it, but I want you to prepare yourself as if everything depends on you."

          -- Dick LeBeau

          Trent


          Good Bad & The Monkey

            Going off patent protection is just one part of the story.  Sometimes, drug companies are permitted to keep price point for a time.

            zoom-zoom


            rectumdamnnearkilledem

              For some reason, the various generic equivalents don't seem to behave precisely the same, even in the same patient.

               

              I know this is a concern with some medications...and we know the name brand med my son is on (Concerta) works well, so why would they even bother messing with the generic if the cost to us is the same.  Given that this drug affects his brain, I'd really rather stick with the known formulation.  I guess we'll give it a try this month, but if there are issues I think we'll definitely be having his ped. write the script differently next time.

               

              On a related note, a friend of mine's son is on the same med and the generic actually costs MORE than the name brand through her ins.  This stuff I simply do not understand...it makes no sense.  I know that sometimes a generic script costs less than an OTC, but that at least makes sense to me, since the OTC doesn't have the benefit of drug coverage plans.

              Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

              remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

                   ~ Sarah Kay

              zoom-zoom


              rectumdamnnearkilledem

                Going off patent protection is just one part of the story.  Sometimes, drug companies are permitted to keep price point for a time.

                 

                Ahh...OK.  The pharm. tech. said something to that effect, but not really explained clearly.  Still seems odd that they wouldn't just fill the script for the name brand, since the script was actually written for the patented drug.

                Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

                remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

                     ~ Sarah Kay

                xor


                  It is possible that your insurance doesn't cover name brand if generic is available.

                   

                  zoom-zoom


                  rectumdamnnearkilledem

                    It is possible that your insurance doesn't cover name brand if generic is available.

                     

                    Ahhh...that I don't know.  We've never before run into a situation where the generic wasn't the preferable choice (price-wise).  You're probably on to something, there.

                    Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

                    remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

                         ~ Sarah Kay

                      It is possible that your insurance doesn't cover name brand if generic is available.

                      That's what I was getting at.  Our insurance covers a fraction of the price of Synthroid since, as they correctly assert, generics are readily available.  But the doc won't write a script for a generic.  Despite her reasoned letter explaining this, they still won't cover it.

                       

                      My quick Googling says Concerta was initially patented, but that the patent was invalidated just last year.  It may be that other manufacturers have "equivalents" as to the methylphenidate but NOT as to the time-release aspect that supported Concerta's brief patent position.  (For the geeks out there: invalidity rested on the sufficiency of the technical disclosure in the patent, not on the compound's (lack of) inventiveness.  So if the disclosure was scarce, maybe that prevented others from duplicating it.)

                      "I want you to pray as if everything depends on it, but I want you to prepare yourself as if everything depends on you."

                      -- Dick LeBeau

                        I know this is a concern with some medications...and we know the name brand med my son is on (Concerta) works well, so why would they even bother messing with the generic if the cost to us is the same.  Given that this drug affects his brain, I'd really rather stick with the known formulation.  I guess we'll give it a try this month, but if there are issues I think we'll definitely be having his ped. write the script differently next time.

                         

                        I'm waiting to see how the generic Concerta plays out before switching anything up too.  The drug is the same, but Concerta's delivery system is fairly intricate.  Secondhand / antecdotal stories seem to indicate the generic may not be delivering as well/smoothly.

                         

                        That sh!t ain't cheap either!  Ouch.

                        zoom-zoom


                        rectumdamnnearkilledem

                          I'm waiting to see how the generic Concerta plays out before switching anything up too.  The drug is the same, but Concerta's delivery system is fairly intricate.  Secondhand / antecdotal stories seem to indicate the generic may not be delivering as well/smoothly.

                           

                          That sh!t ain't cheap either!  Ouch.

                           

                          Yeah.  $35/month isn't even as bad as what a lot of people pay for it.  Crazy.

                          Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

                          remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

                               ~ Sarah Kay

                          zoom-zoom


                          rectumdamnnearkilledem

                            My quick Googling says Concerta was initially patented, but that the patent was invalidated just last year.  It may be that other manufacturers have "equivalents" as to the methylphenidate but NOT as to the time-release aspect that supported Concerta's brief patent position.  (For the geeks out there: invalidity rested on the sufficiency of the technical disclosure in the patent, not on the compound's (lack of) inventiveness.  So if the disclosure was scarce, maybe that prevented others from duplicating it.)

                             

                            Most ADHD drugs have the same active ingredient...what gets patented is the delivery method, as you noted with Concerta.  Kinda crazy that a drug company can take an ingredient, change the delivery system, then claim a brand new patent.  But this happened with Albuterol when the CFC propellant was banned.  Suddenly my generic rescue inhaler became name brand, again...and the new propellant is utter crap.  It clogs the mouthpiece and requires frequent rinsing.  So the inhaler I keep in my purse for sudden attacks doesn't always work.  Really sucks balls when I'm driving and discover this.  Today I was hacking away and had to stop at a rest area to rinse out my inhaler.  So I'm paying $35 for a device that doesn't really work when I need it to.

                            Getting the wind knocked out of you is the only way to

                            remind your lungs how much they like the taste of air.    

                                 ~ Sarah Kay

                              Yeah.  $35/month isn't even as bad as what a lot of people pay for it.  Crazy.

                               

                               

                              Yeah, I meant the full retail price... about $240/mo if you're rollin' up w/o insurance.

                                Have a talk with him about sneaking drinks.  I know this is random, but the other night we had an issue with a kid who's on Adderall and snuck away to have a few drinks with his buddy.  Paramedics, the whole nine. He's a pretty big kid and didn't drink too much.   I know yours is young yet, but boys will be boys.  

                                "If you have the fire, run..." -John Climacus