Beginners and Beyond

1

Foam roller foolishness? (Read 107 times)

obiebyke


    Hello from the sidelines, guys. I'm a coughing fool, so I've taken the week off. I also had what I think was a calf pull a week ago, so I've been resting that and finally got a foam roller this week. It's awesome (but painful)!

     

    I had dinner with a runner friend yesterday who said her chiropractor says no to foam rollers. The chiro said while it may break up scar tissue in the short run, rubbing a large unfocused area into the bone creates MORE scar tissue in the long run. I'm not a big fan of chiros, and I kind of called B.S. and plan to keep rolling. What do you think?

     

    Opinions welcome. Links to studies about foam roller efficacy even more welcome.

    Call me Ray (not Ishmael)

    LRB


      I do not own one and have never used one but the masses swear by them by a ratio of something ridiculous like 10 to 1, so there has to be something there?

        Plenty of people say no to chiropractors too, so there's that.

         

        Basically, what LRB said. I have never used one, but I kind of feel left out, because it seems a high % of people on these forums do.

         

        BTW - you know what is REALLY bad for you, probably THE WORST thing you can do for your bones & joints? Running.

        Dave


        Hip Redux

          I guess my massage therapist would be a no-no too, then.  lol

           

            My chiropractor recommended foam rolling. And my foam roller came with a warning that says not to roll over bony areas. Oops, that sort of limits its usefulness, doesn't it? And I agree - painfully awesome.

            RSX


              I use it on occasion. My chiro does ART, and it helps me a lot. she will lecture me when I slip that I haven't used the roller lately.

                I use it on occasion. My chiro does ART, and it helps me a lot. she will lecture me when I slip that I haven't used the roller lately.

                 

                Is it like seeing your dentist when you haven't been flossing?

                Dave

                happylily


                  Are we supposed to roll all the time? I have a stick, not the foam type, what's the difference between the two? I only use mine if I have real pain/tightness in an area. Like, to an extreme. Otherwise, I just endure the usual after run discomfort that follows speedwork or a LR. I think pain foolishly makes me feel hardcore. I'm stupid like that. Joking

                  PRs: Boston Marathon, 3:27, April 15th 2013

                          Cornwall Half-Marathon, 1:35, April 27th 2013

                  18 marathons, 18 BQs since 2010


                  Chasing the bus

                    Are we supposed to roll all the time? I have a stick, not the foam type, what's the difference between the two? I only use mine if I have real pain/tightness in an area. Like, to an extreme. Otherwise, I just endure the usual after run discomfort that follows speedwork or a LR. I think pain foolishly makes me feel hardcore. I'm stupid like that. Joking

                     

                    I have stuff I have to roll proactively or I can't run. Roller keeps me on the road. Wouldn't be running without it right now.

                    “You're either on the bus or off the bus.”
                    Tom Wolfe, The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test

                    tracilynn


                      Foam rollers take $ out of chiro's pockets

                      ~~~~~~~

                      Traci

                       

                      obiebyke


                        That's my thought, tracilynn.

                         

                        I'm digging the responses.

                        Call me Ray (not Ishmael)

                        StepbyStep-SH


                          Since the idea of a 30-minute massage several times a week to keep my glute and lower back muscle loose is a little out of range of my budget, I'll stick with the foam roller, and an hour massage every few weeks where she can really pinpoint the problem areas with an elbow and lots of "hurts so good" pain.

                          20,000 miles behind me, the world still to see.