Beginners and Beyond

123

Garmin 235 or 935. Which way should I go? (Read 63 times)

DanFuller


5K Specialist

    Time to upgrade the Garmin 610. I want the wrist heart rate monitor and smart features. Looks like my options are the 235, 735, and 935. I am not a triathlete so I see no reason to go for the 735. That leaves the 235 and 935. I am strongly leaning towards the 235 because I am a old fart that probably will not use the advanced training features in the 935. The shiny, new 935 is hard to find, and it is $200 extra dollars that I will not have to spend. What do y'all think?

    Personal Bests:

    800M - 2:38 (5/28/13) | 1 Mile -5:54 (5/28/13) | 3K - 11:55 (12/29/12) | 2M - 13:00 (12/1/12) | 5K - 20:00 (4/12/13) | 13.1M - 1:37:24 (2/3/13)

    Zelanie


      I don't know what the 935 has that I don't, but I have the 235 and I like it. I can program screens to have a track screen and a regular screen, plus I get heart rate, recovery, and v02 max info. That's plenty for me.

      DanFuller


      5K Specialist

        Thanks Z. The last 200 series Garmin I had was in 2011-2012. It was pretty basic. It sounds like the new ones are closer to what the 600 was when I purchased the 610 plus some added features which sounds good enough for me.

        Personal Bests:

        800M - 2:38 (5/28/13) | 1 Mile -5:54 (5/28/13) | 3K - 11:55 (12/29/12) | 2M - 13:00 (12/1/12) | 5K - 20:00 (4/12/13) | 13.1M - 1:37:24 (2/3/13)

        Zelanie


          Thanks Z. The last 200 series Garmin I had was in 2011-2012. It was pretty basic. It sounds like the new ones are closer to what the 600 was when I purchased the 610 plus some added features which sounds good enough for me.

           

          I replaced a 600 series with it and it was a step up.

          Cyberic


             I am not a triathlete so I see no reason to go for the 735. That leaves the 235 and 935. 

             

            The 935 is also a triathlon watch.

             

            MTA: Hmm, I was kinda wrong. It IS a tri-watch, but DcRainmaker has it as a "triathlon/multisport…and running-specific focused watch"

             

            https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2017/03/garmin-forerunner-935-depth-review.html


            delicate flower

               

              The 935 is also a triathlon watch.

               

              Released like a week ago which is why it's probably hard to find...lot of suckers jumping on the new release.  I will not buy a new model until it's been out for at least a year.

               

              Dan, if all you are doing is running, the 935 will be way overkill.

              <3

                 

                 

                Dan, if all you are doing is running, the 935 will be way overkill.

                 

                I don't even know what the 935 does, but I can't imagine needing more than my 220, which is of course a couple notches below the 235.

                Dave

                DanFuller


                5K Specialist

                  I got the 235.

                  Likes - HRM, charger is huge improvement over 610, Will do my first run with it a lunchtime so I will what I think of it as a running watch. The HRM seems to measure my resting heartrate at slightly below what I think it should.

                  Personal Bests:

                  800M - 2:38 (5/28/13) | 1 Mile -5:54 (5/28/13) | 3K - 11:55 (12/29/12) | 2M - 13:00 (12/1/12) | 5K - 20:00 (4/12/13) | 13.1M - 1:37:24 (2/3/13)

                    charger is huge improvement over 610

                     

                    Before my 220, I had a 210 which had the notoriously finicky clip charger. The charger for the 220 has been rock solid; I assume the 235 uses the same one. This is a life-changing improvement; the other is the built-in accelerometer which lets you start running before it picks up a sattelite.

                    Dave


                    delicate flower

                       charger

                       

                      My Garmin progression has gone from 410 to 610 to 620 to 920.  Also, DW has owned a 910 and a swim watch.  Every charger has been different.  THAT is annoying.

                       

                      I have owned three android smartphones over the years and the charger has not changed.

                      <3

                      DanFuller


                      5K Specialist

                         

                        My Garmin progression has gone from 410 to 610 to 620 to 920.  Also, DW has owned a 910 and a swim watch.  Every charger has been different.  THAT is annoying.

                         

                        I have owned three android smartphones over the years and the charger has not changed.

                         

                        Third Garmin and third different charger. The 610 was the worst of the three. You would have to get it just right or it doesn't charge.

                        Personal Bests:

                        800M - 2:38 (5/28/13) | 1 Mile -5:54 (5/28/13) | 3K - 11:55 (12/29/12) | 2M - 13:00 (12/1/12) | 5K - 20:00 (4/12/13) | 13.1M - 1:37:24 (2/3/13)

                        LRB


                          410, 220, 620, 630 for me. I've never had an issue with charging any of them. :knocks on wood:

                          DanFuller


                          5K Specialist

                            The best part is that I have buttons now instead of that annoying touch bezel.

                            Personal Bests:

                            800M - 2:38 (5/28/13) | 1 Mile -5:54 (5/28/13) | 3K - 11:55 (12/29/12) | 2M - 13:00 (12/1/12) | 5K - 20:00 (4/12/13) | 13.1M - 1:37:24 (2/3/13)

                            LRB


                              I forgot all about the touch bezel on my 410!

                               

                              I actually didn't mind the bezel, it was waiting an eternity to acquire a satellite that stuck in my craw. There were days when I stood outside in the freezing cold and darkness waiting five and sometimes ten minutes to run.

                              Cyberic


                                I forgot all about the touch bezel on my 410!

                                 

                                I actually didn't mind the bezel, it was waiting an eternity to acquire a satellite that stuck in my craw. There were days when I stood outside in the freezing cold and darkness waiting five and sometimes ten minutes to run.

                                 

                                Yeah, that's really the best part about the newer watches.

                                123